
I grew these pickling cucumbers this year specifically to make homemade pickles. I’ve been making them for a couple years now, but I always bought cucumbers from Conrad’s in the past. These are so easy to make and SO good for you. Looking for more ways to get probiotics in your diet? These are for you.
These are naturally fermented pickles. They will not be canned. Canning is a way to preserve your garden bounty, but the process of heating will kill all the beneficial enzymes, vitamins, and friendly bacteria.
If you’re new to naturally fermented foods, you may be thinking, “Ewww, I don’t want to eat something fermented!” But lots of food you already enjoy is fermented–vinegar, sauerkraut, kimchi, wine, beer, cheese, yogurt, miso–to name a few. Even more food was fermented back in the days before canning. It is a natural way to preserve food. This is how people back in Bible times kept food from spoiling without refrigerators. Fermenting actually increases the vitamin content of food. Eating some fermented food every day aids digestion.
I like to use a cross between a recipe from Wild Fermentation and Nourishing Traditions.
You will need:
-filtered water
-sea salt (If Celtic, make sure to sterilize, like I mentioned here.)
-dill seeds or fresh dill heads
-mustard seeds (optional)
-few garlic cloves
-cucumbers, either whole, sliced, or cut in spears
-whey (optional)
-glass jars or crock
-something to weigh down and keep the cukes submerged (see photo)

I mix 6 tablespoons of Celtic Sea Salt with 8 cups of filtered water, stir to dissolve.
Place a couple cloves peeled garlic in each jar, add seasonings, dill and mustard, if using. Add cucumbers to the jar. If you are using whey (this just gives them a little kick-start on fermenting, it’s not essential), add a couple tablespoons to each jar. Then cover with brine. If you need to mix up more brine, do so with the above ratio. You will need enough brine to cover the cucumbers and you will want to leave about an inch of head room.
Now for the important part–you need to weigh your cucumbers down so that they stay submerged. Any part of the cucumber that is above the brine level will rot and have to be thrown out. If you’re using a big crock, you can use a plate to weigh them down. I use mason jars (see above picture), so I use little plastic containers filled with dry beans as my weights.
You will now leave these cucumbers out at room temperature to ferment. I do mine for 5 days. The bigger your cucumbers the longer the ferment. If you leave your cucumbers whole, it will take longer. I always slice mine, like you see in the picture.
You will see the liquid turn cloudy (that is good!) and the cucumbers turn from bright green to the darker pickle color. Cover your container with a cloth to keep flies away. After they are done fermenting, store in the fridge (with lids on the jars).
Now at this point, your germaphobia may be telling you that you can’t leave cucumbers out on the counter for 5 days! But this is wrong. Bacteria and mold cannot survive in certain conditions, salt and acid are two of those conditions. The brine you made is very salty, nothing bad can live in it, that’s why we have to keep the cucumbers in that brine. If they poke above the liquid, they aren’t protected and will mold and rot. In the process of fermentation the sugars are turning to acids and that keeps baddies from growing, too. Good bacteria are multiplying and keeping bad stuff at bay as well. If you want to learn more, click here.
Oddly enough, even though the brine starts out very salty, it changes during fermentation. These pickles are not too salty. If your’s taste too salty, let them ferment longer.
You will need to check on your pickles every day and skim any mold that is growing on the surface. It’s not essential to get all of it, just do your best. Again, I know this sounds weird, but don’t worry, the pickles in the brine are safe. This is how true kosher pickles are made. This is how pickles were made in barrels for hundreds of years. Unfortunately all pickles sold in regular grocery stores are only vinegar-soaked, not truly fermented, and so they don’t have the same health qualities. In addition, store pickles are then pasteurized/heat sealed, which kills them. These pickles are a living food and will last for months in your fridge.
If you are concerned with how these will taste, you can buy Bubbie’s at Whole Foods (sold in the refrigerator section, next to the cheese and yogurt). They are made the same way I have detailed. Bubbie’s are spicier, though.
Also, an added bonus–you will have pickled garlic–a wonderful, natural antibiotic. The garlic takes longer to pickle than the cucumbers. Typically the garlic is ready when the pickles are all gone. If the garlic taste like a pickle, you know it’s done. If it still tastes strong, like garlic, then you know it’s not done and you can just leave it in the jar, in the fridge. I beat colds and flu with garlic, but it’s much, much easier to eat when it’s pickled! My kids will eat it, too, and love it! Occasionally, I will drink some of the pickle brine, too, since it has lots of good stuff, good acids, good bacteria (probiotics), probably some essence of the garlic, etc.
These are easy (probably takes me 30 minutes or less), but they require a little patience (you don’t get to eat them for a few days), but it is SO worth it! Hope you enjoy!

21 comments
Comments feed for this article
August 5, 2009 at 1:45 pm
John
Thank you for this fabulous post about fermented pickles! I have been wanting to make fermented food for years and didn’t find enough to make it a habit. Now I’m excited to get going with this new adventure. I have subscribed to your blog and am looking forward to using your valuable information as a guide.
August 6, 2009 at 7:16 pm
Jenny @ Nourished Kitchen
Lovely! We did a gallon about 2 weeks ago, and I’m doing another gallon tomorrow. I love true sour pickles. They’re the best.
August 7, 2009 at 10:23 pm
Erica
Love your post! I have plans to make these this weekend, we made Dilly Beans earlier this week and they are delicious also….but I’m swimming in cucumbers and zucchini haha!
August 10, 2009 at 9:24 am
LW
WOW! my 4 year old is going to LOVE this!
thanks!
September 2, 2009 at 12:55 pm
judy
I’ve read from Nourishing Traditions that you should use the whey of kefir or yogurt but not the whey of cheese, do you know why this is?
September 2, 2009 at 9:15 pm
Shannon
Judy,
I do not know why you wouldn’t want to use the whey from cheese. I will look into that.
September 6, 2009 at 6:41 pm
John
Can you make zucchini like this also?
Thank You
September 7, 2009 at 7:54 am
Shannon
John,
I have never made pickled zucchini, but searching online, it looks like you can do it, the same way I did with the cucumbers. Here’s a link to an article with general information – http://www.wildfermentation.com/resources.php?page=vegetables
Give it a try. Try some different seasonings, if you like. Let us know how they turn out. I’m going to try pickling jalapeno peppers this week. I’ll post my pictures and results.
September 14, 2009 at 5:41 am
John
There is white stuff floating around in the jar, is that ok?
September 14, 2009 at 6:26 am
Shannon
Your brine will become cloudy–that is good. There will be white stuff on the surface, you can skim that off every day. I was told it was a type of yeast. I have read that even if some gets in the brine, it’s okay.
September 14, 2009 at 1:13 pm
Pickled Jalapeno Peppers « All Things Health
[...] As you can see some of them have turned red. I love the color they add to the jars. I followed my basic sour pickle recipe, with the changes noted above. I also ran out of celtic sea salt and had to use some of my kosher [...]
September 22, 2009 at 5:37 pm
John
My pickles taste a little bland. Do I add more dill and mustard seed?
September 22, 2009 at 6:04 pm
Shannon
Perhaps. Did you put in some garlic cloves? I haven’t had mine turn out bland. I did have a batch turn out too salty. I left them in the fridge a few weeks and they toned down. You could try leaving them in the fridge and see if they develop more flavor. They should sour more over time.
October 20, 2009 at 10:48 pm
Pickle Dude
How exactly do you make the brine? Should I heat it up and stir in the salt? Also, how much dill and pickle spices should I put in? I already made one batch. There is some kind of bubbling action going on at the top. I have the pickles pushed down far enough but the seeds are exposed a little because they float around the thing I have stuffed in the jar to keep the pickles down. Also, there is a lot of sediment at the bottom. Garlic, seeds and whatever else. Should I stir it up once in an while? Water seams to rise up around the rim and drain down the sides, then I refill it a little to keep the pickles covered and it does it again.
I only have three more days until I try one! Do you think it will be ok from what I stated above?
October 21, 2009 at 7:35 am
Shannon
I just use room temp water and stir until the salt dissolves. When I use Celtic salt, it doesn’t seem to dissolve all the way, but I still use it.
It sounds like your pickles are behaving normally. There are usually bubble in ferments. The brine level will sometimes rise and yes, spill over like you mentioned. I’ve had seeds float and never had a problem, it’s when the pickles rise above the brine where problems come in.
Sediment is also normal. I don’t stir. I just let them sit and do their thing. Bubbie’s pickles say to shake before serving.
I probably use about 1/2 tsp dill seeds and 1/2 tsp mustard seeds in each quart jar. But I don’t measure so it depends from time to time.
Hope this helps!
October 26, 2009 at 9:48 pm
Pickle Dude
The pickles have been in the brine for 11 days now. They are less salty, but still very salty. Should I put them in new water and put them in the fridge now? Or should I ferment them longer? Also, if I ferment them longer, will the salt disappear enough for mold to grow?
October 27, 2009 at 6:07 am
Shannon
When my pickles were overly salty I put them in the fridge for a few weeks to ferment slower and they lose the saltiness. But you could leave them out if you want. Sandor Katz in Wild Fermentation says to leave them out until they taste right and he says that could take a while (I’ll have to look up how long he says).
October 27, 2009 at 7:39 pm
Pickle Dude
Also, I have mine cut just like your example. I thought you might need to know that as fermenting the whole pickle may take even longer.
October 27, 2009 at 7:59 pm
Shannon
Yes, good to note, the bigger the pickle, the longer the ferment.
October 29, 2009 at 11:10 pm
Pickle Dude
I have the pickles in the fridge now. They taste fine, but I think I used to much spices. How do I make the pickles hot?
October 30, 2009 at 6:01 am
Shannon
I have not ever made spicy pickles, but you could probably add some red pepper flakes or some fresh jalapeno and have success.